Wednesday, 11 November 2015

Common Sense vs. Ryan Gosling

Common Sense vs. Ryan Gosling
(is there even a question here?) 

With reference to Thomas Paine's influential publication during the American Revolution, Common Sense is a prime historical example of virality. It evolved into a highly influential medium targeting political, economic, social and cultural practices. With the example of Thomas Paine, a pamphlet was released that was in favour of American independence. It was a counter-culture movement, originally named Plain Truth, then renamed to Common Sense. Intellectuals were naming it a "masterly irresistible performance" and it facilitated a working change for the minds of many American individuals. The pamphlet released by Paine increasingly circulated across several states, and it gained exponential popularity."Common Sense was now being read aloud in homes, shops, taverns and coffeehouses" (Standage 143).  It had become an integrated discourse of shifted attitudes, beliefs and values surrounding the American life.  An important element of Standage's segment on Thomas Paine, is that he notes that "Common Sense acted as a means of signaling and synchronizing opinion. This sentence really stuck out to me when looking at contemporary practices of virality - specifically pop culture memes.

The meme that I chose is  the Ryan Gosling, "Hey Girl_______ [insert some sexy/luring comment for women]". There are many different versions of this meme, but they are quite popular among the 16-25 aged young-female crowd.

The most popular Ryan Gosling meme

Ryan Gosling meme transformed into more motivational memes for women. 


After considering the virality of Paine's 18th century pamphlet and the virality of the 21st century Ryan Gosling meme, I am able to draw some parallels. Specifically, as quoted above, Common Sense acted as a means of signaling and synchronizing opinion. Perhaps the Ryan Gosling meme did not or does not have quite the same political and cultural impact as Paine's Revolution pamphlet, yet it similarly sparked a new or transformed way of interpreting Ryan Gosling. As the well-known Hollywood actor (who is consistently recognized for his good looks and charm) these memes perpetuate a particular synchronous opinion about him, primarily among young women. We look at him as a fantasy lover, and use these memes as elements of motivation or affirmation. Just like Paine's pamphlet it provoked particular thoughts and created a sense of common understanding or belonging. 

One last thing to note that is relevant is the mass circulation that Common Sense reached. This is also shown through the media practice of memes as they are mass circulated on the internet and across every social media platform. Just like the pamphlet became a part of every American household, memes (including my boy Ryan Gosling) illustrate how we interact with others, are representative of our contemporary imagination, show our understanding and influence of celebrity culture and highlight the culture of connectivity that we live in today. 



4 comments:

  1. Something that came to mind while contemplating the Ryan Gosling memes, is the concept of what in particular goes viral. With the Common Sense pamphlet, there was a strong political, economic, social and cultural significance within the American Revolution. The messages being communicated were important and affected people's lives. It was more significant for the pamphlet to "go viral" both because of the subject matter but also because of the time period. Today, we can effortlessly circulate anything. Sometimes I wonder if the right things are going viral. We spend a lot of time looking at Ryan Gosling memes, cat videos, and Ermahgerd for example, but perhaps we should be circulating photos/articles and information that might have the power to affect change and inform/educate the general public, if seen. Just food for thought.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good post. :) I really enjoy the Ryan Gosling meme's because lets be honest, who isn't a fan of him? But, when it comes to the concept of what goes viral in regards to the "Common Sense" Pamphlet, we can see that the importance of the message affected people's lives. Whereas, we can now see that meme's like this Ryan Gosling one are going viral but not for the same reasons. Although I enjoy the meme and Ryan Gosling, I think we can all see that the power of it vitality does not have the same affect of something like "Common Sense".

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great post! Thanks for sharing :) Going to have to agree with the above posts, all great thoughts and comments. Great example with the Ryan Gosling meme, hadn't thought about this one in the context of our course topics. Going off what Lindsay commented, its great to question what is going viral. In this week's reading Nancy Baym discusses in chapter six of her book digital media in everyday relationships. Baym illustrates how digital media fits into the landscape of interpersonal communication.Baym wrote, media choice carries relational messages" (160). I agree that the Ryan Gosling 'Hey Girl' meme does not have the same political impact as Paine's revolution pamphlet but it does say something about our culture and interpersonal communications. The 'Hey Girl' meme was created to empower and lift women's spirits, through a vast circulation of sharing this meme became viral which says something about our culture and everyday relationships and interactions.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really like your example of Ryan Gosling and how there are different ways of communicating with one another and mimes are the new thing. Compared to Common Sense we have come a long way and I think it is important to know that technology and the way we communicate changes what we communicate about and what we think about. Technology can change our issues and concerns and overall alter our very existence!

    ReplyDelete