A common
characteristic both examples reflect is their ability to be relatable. In Paine’s
pamphlet he spoke about the American Revolution in a way that most could
understand. He ignored the common philosophical, elite way of writing and
instead wrote to the common people so that everyone could grasp what he was
trying to say. This reminds me of a scene in the television show called Master of None where a television
producer is talking about how to create a popular show and says that in order
for it to be widely accepted it must target the lowest common denominator. Paine’s
use of this notion lead to the virality of his pamphlet and also holds true for
society today. All of these memes and YouTube videos that have achieved virality
are simplistic, that everyone can understand.
I think one of the largest changes between what it means to go
viral in the past and what it means now can be easily related to the transition
from mass media to social media. Before social media took dominance in our
lives, the spread of information was largely reliant on mass media. Although
Paine published Common Sense by an
alias name he still had the connections to get his work out to the public. Back
then when mass media was our only viable outlet we had to rely on these people
who had the tools and knowhow to spread information as it was not readily
available to the public as it is now. During Paine’s time, even looking back
five to ten years the only famous people were those on mass media such as
television shows and movies but now we have progressed to a time where any
average Joe can upload a video or photo, share it to the world, and become
famous overnight. Now this is not to say that anyone can achieve this but if
they have Kevin Allocca's three means to go viral; tastemakers,
communities of participation, and an aspect of unexpectedness becoming an
internet success is a possibility. Common
Sense too had content in it that was of controversial subject matter,
therefore it has the same sense of the unexpectedness that content today needs
to become viral as many newspapers would not have published his work because of
its provocative message.
Looking at the two articulations involved with media
mode of production also helps set apart the past and present’s ability to
achieve virality. The first articulation that concentrates on the modes of
communication, affect, and accumulation. Standage argues that new media is not
as new as we perceive it to be, that in fact when it is stripped down to its
basic role in relation to the first articulation I believe he is correct.
Regardless if its Common Sense or the plethora of “Hotline Bling” memes they
both achieve to create a symbolic meaning through social practices, invoke a
certain emotion and spark a connection in people’s lives, and lastly accumulate
capital or power. He also is correct that both examples contain all aspects of
the second articulation as well but they ways in which they do so shows how
they differ. In both forms of media in order for them to go viral they need to
be produced, circulated, and then consumed. In Common Sense Paine's work is
produced by himself first wherever he wrote his work and then had it
transformed by the printing press. Once that was completed he distributed it
through newspapers as that was the most effective medium to reach a multiple
number of people at that time. Lastly his work was consumed by the people, the
support through tastemakers, the large community of people he was targeting,
and the pamphlets shocking and appealing information are what allowed it to
spread the way it did which eventually lead to him being classified as one of
the Founding Fathers of the United States. Looking at the virality of Drake's
"Hotline Bling" memes the social media platforms that are now
accessible has allowed for it to be shared through multiple means
simultaneously. Medium likes YouTube, Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram being
the main contenders has allowed for much greater distribution than Paine was
capable of, sharing these memes to people all around the world in a matter of
seconds. With the greater range of production new media provides for media
texts leads to greater distribution and therefore a much
higher consumption. Social media has allotted the capability to perform
all three steps of production, distribution, and consumption involved in the
second articulation simultaneously, at the same time. This allows people to go
viral at such a fast pace, Paine was not able to do this with Common Sense
because he had to perform each step separately therefore at a much slower pace.
That and the fact that the power of what goes viral is more controlled by the
people or consumers as they now have the means for participation that they
never had before leading to a more centralized power versus mass media
where the elite were the only ones with the means and decided what was going to
be shared and what was important.
I really enjoyed your post and how you compared Payne to the Hotline Bling memes. With the increase in mediums, compared to word of mouth, I agree, that it is much easier for things to become viral more quickly to a further distance. I also enjoyed how your expanded beyond the medium of the Internet and mentioned other mediums like Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and etc.
ReplyDelete